email-marketing-bible

>

SKILL.md

---
name: email-marketing-bible
description: >
  Comprehensive, data-backed email marketing knowledge base. 908 sources,
  4,798 insights. Use when reviewing email setups, building automation flows,
  diagnosing deliverability, writing email copy, selecting platforms, or pulling
  benchmarks. Covers strategy, flows, deliverability, copywriting, segmentation,
  compliance, cold email, and 19 industry playbooks.
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: george-hartley
  version: "0.4"
---

# Email Marketing Bible — Skill Reference

> Source: EMB v0.4 (~55K words, 16 chapters, 4 appendices). Feb 2026.
> Full guide: https://emailmarketingskill.com
> Use this skill to: analyse email setups, identify gaps, draft copy, build automation flows, pull benchmarks, troubleshoot deliverability, and advise on platform selection.
> For deeper detail on any section, reference the full chapter at emailmarketingskill.com.

---

## 1. FUNDAMENTALS

### Why Email Wins
- ROI: $36 per $1 spent (3,600%). Newsletter-as-business: 122%. Social: 28%. Paid search: 25%.
- 89% of marketers use email as primary lead gen channel. 51% of consumers prefer email from brands.
- Email is owned media — no algorithm throttling, no platform risk.
- Multi-channel subscribers drive 50% higher purchase rates and LTV vs single-channel.

### The Email Stack (6 components)
1. **ESP** — sending platform (Klaviyo, Mailchimp, etc.). See Section 12.
2. **Authentication** — SPF, DKIM, DMARC. Non-negotiable since Feb 2024 Google/Yahoo rules.
3. **List management** — quality > size. 5K engaged beats 50K messy.
4. **Content & design** — 60%+ opens on mobile. Mobile-first is essential.
5. **Automation** — flows generate 30x more RPR than campaigns. Set up flows before campaigns.
6. **Analytics** — 21% of marketers don't measure ROI. Don't be one of them.

### Key Metrics & Benchmarks

| Metric | Good | Strong | Red Flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| Click-through rate | 2-3% | 4%+ | Below 1% |
| Click-to-open rate | 10-15% | 20%+ | Below 5% |
| Unsubscribe rate | Under 0.2% | Under 0.1% | Above 0.5% |
| Bounce rate | Under 2% | Under 1% | Above 3% |
| Spam complaint rate | Under 0.1% | Under 0.05% | Above 0.3% |
| List growth rate | 3-5%/month | 5%+/month | Negative |
| Delivery rate | 95%+ | 98%+ | Below 85% |
| Inbox placement | 85-94% | 94%+ | Below 70% |

**Post-Apple MPP:** Open rates are directional only. Use click-based metrics as primary.

### Tags vs Segments vs Lists
- **Lists:** Use ONE master list. Multiple lists = duplicate subscribers, inconsistent data.
- **Tags:** Labels on subscribers (facts). Applied manually or via automation.
- **Segments:** Dynamic groups based on rules. Auto-update as conditions change.
- Minimum segments: new (last 30 days), engaged (clicked last 60 days), customers vs non-customers, lapsed (90+ days).

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/01-fundamentals/

---

## 2. LIST BUILDING

### Organic Growth
- **Lead magnets:** Templates/swipe files convert highest. Free template increased signups by 384%.
- **Content upgrades:** 5-10x better opt-in vs generic sidebar forms.
- **Signup forms:** Form > link (20-50% more opt-ins). "Get my templates" > "Subscribe" (33% lift).

### Popups
- Well-timed popups: 3-5% conversion. Top 10%: 9.28%.
- Exit-intent: 4-7%. Two-step popups: 30-50% better than single-step.

### Double vs Single Opt-in
- Double opt-in recommended for most. Validates addresses, prevents bots/traps, GDPR-ready.
- Compromise: single opt-in for purchasers, double for lead magnets/popups.

### List Hygiene & Spam Traps
- Lists decay 22-30% annually. Unengaged subscribers cost money AND hurt deliverability.
- **Sunset flow:** Reduce frequency → re-engagement series (2-3 emails) → suppress non-responders.
- **Spam traps:** Pristine (honeypots), recycled (abandoned addresses), typo (gnail.com), role-based (info@).
- **Prevention:** Double opt-in, real-time validation at signup, regular list cleaning, engagement-based sending.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/02-building-your-list/

---

## 3. SEGMENTATION & PERSONALISATION

### Personalisation Hierarchy (most to least impactful)
1. **Behavioural:** Product recs from browse/purchase history. Highest impact.
2. **Lifecycle:** Different content for new, active, VIP, at-risk, lapsed.
3. **Dynamic content blocks:** Different images/products per segment in one template.
4. **Send-time:** Per-subscriber optimal timing.
5. **Location-based:** Weather, events, timezone, nearby stores.
6. **Name/demographic:** Fine as addition, not meaningful alone.

### RFM Quick Start
Simple version: segment by recency of last purchase into 4 groups:
1. Purchased last 30 days (active)
2. 31-90 days ago (warm)
3. 91-180 days ago (cooling)
4. 180+ days ago (cold)

### Engagement-Based Sending (highest-impact optimisation)
- **Tier 1:** Clicked last 30 days → every campaign
- **Tier 2:** Clicked last 60 days → 75% of sends
- **Tier 3:** Clicked last 90 days → best content only (50%)
- **Tier 4:** No engagement 90-180 days → re-engagement flow only
- **Tier 5:** 180+ days → sunset flow
- Results: 15-30% better open rates, 20-40% fewer complaints, revenue stays flat or increases.

### Waterfall Segmentation (prevents "three emails in one day")
Priority: Abandoned cart → Post-purchase → Browse abandonment → Win-back → Promotional.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/03-segmentation-and-personalisation/

---

## 4. AUTOMATION FLOWS (Revenue Engines)

### Automations vs Campaigns

| Metric | Automations | Campaigns |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue per recipient | 30x higher | Baseline |
| Open rate | 40-55% | 15-25% |
| Click rate | 5-10% | 2-3% |

### Flow Priority Order (by revenue impact per setup hour)
1. Welcome series → 2. Abandoned cart → 3. Browse abandonment → 4. Post-purchase → 5. Win-back → 6. Cross-sell/upsell → 7. VIP/loyalty → 8. Sunset → 9. Birthday → 10. Replenishment → 11. Back-in-stock → 12. Price drop

### Welcome Series (4-6 emails, 1-2 weeks)
- Open rate: 51-55%. Revenue: 320% more per email vs promotional.
- **Email 1 (immediate):** Deliver promise + ask for reply + one segmentation question.
- **Email 2 (Day 2):** Brand story.
- **Email 3 (Day 4):** Social proof.
- **Email 4 (Day 7):** Best content/product using segmentation data.
- **Email 5 (Day 10):** Soft sell.
- **Email 6 (Day 14):** Set expectations + preference centre link.

### Abandoned Cart (3 emails)
- 70% of carts abandoned. Recovery: 17.12% conversion. Top 10%: $3.07 RPR.
- **Email 1 (1-4h):** Simple reminder. NO discount.
- **Email 2 (24h):** Address objections. Reviews, shipping, guarantee.
- **Email 3 (48h):** Small incentive if margins allow. First-time abandoners only.

### Post-Purchase Sequence
Immediately: Order confirmation → Day 2-3: Shipping → Day 7-10: Satisfaction check → Day 14: Review request → Day 21-30: Cross-sell → Day 25-30: Replenishment (consumables).

### Win-Back (target 60-90 day inactive)
1. "We miss you" → 2. Value offer → 3. Breakup email (highest reply rate) → 4. Confirmation + re-subscribe link.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/04-the-emails-that-make-money/

---

## 5. COPYWRITING

### Subject Lines
- 64% decide to open based on subject line. Under 25 chars = highest opens.
- Personalisation: +14% opens. First-person CTA > second-person (25-35% lift).

### Body Copy
- Inverted pyramid: key message first. Short paragraphs. Write, then cut 30%.
- 3:1 ratio: three value emails per one promotional.

### Copywriting Frameworks
- **AIDA:** Attention → Interest → Desire → Action. Best for promotional.
- **PAS:** Problem → Agitate → Solution. Best for cold email, B2B.
- **BAB:** Before → After → Bridge. Best for case studies.
- **Soap Opera Sequence (Chaperon):** Multi-email narrative. 70%+ open rates deep in sequence.
- **1-3-1 Newsletter:** One big story + three shorter items + one CTA.

### CTAs
- Buttons > text links (+27% CTR). Single CTA: +42% clicks vs multiple.
- Place CTA above fold AND below main content (+35% total clicks).

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/05-copywriting-that-converts/

---

## 6. DESIGN & TECHNICAL

- 60%+ opens on mobile. Single-column layouts. Width: 600-640px. Touch targets: 44x44px.
- Font: 14-16px body, 20-22px headlines. Images: under 200KB each, total under 800KB.
- Dark mode (33%+): Transparent PNGs, off-white backgrounds, `@media (prefers-color-scheme: dark)`.
- Accessibility: 4.5:1 contrast, alt text, logical reading order.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/06-design-and-technical/

---

## 7. DELIVERABILITY

### Authentication (all three required)
- **SPF:** DNS TXT record listing authorised sending IPs. 10 DNS lookup limit. End with `-all`.
- **DKIM:** 2048-bit RSA keys. Rotate annually. `d=` domain must align with From address.
- **DMARC:** Implement in stages: `p=none` → `p=quarantine` → `p=reject`.
- **BIMI:** Brand logo in inbox. Requires DMARC enforcement + VMC (~$1,500/year).
- **Order:** SPF → DKIM → DMARC (p=none) → advance DMARC → BIMI.

### Sender Reputation
- Domain reputation > IP reputation for Gmail (120-day window).
- Dedicated IP: only if sending 1M+/month. Below that, shared IPs are fine.

### Sending Identity
- Separate marketing from transactional: different subdomains. Worth it at 40K+/month.
- From name: personal names get +3.81% opens. Always set monitored reply-to.

### Deliverability Diagnosis (10-step framework)
1. Identify symptom → 2. Check authentication → 3. Check blocklists → 4. Check reputation → 5. Analyse bounce logs → 6. Review sending patterns → 7. Check content → 8. Test and validate → 9. Remediate root cause → 10. Monitor recovery (2-4 weeks, Gmail up to 120 days).

### Domain/IP Warming
Days 1-3: 50-100 → Days 4-7: 200-500 → Week 2: 500-1K → Week 3: 1-5K → Week 4: 5-10K → Week 5+: Scale to full. Start with most engaged subscribers.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/07-deliverability/

---

## 8. TESTING & OPTIMISATION

- **Highest priority tests:** Sender name (compounds), CTA format, template structure.
- Only 1 in 7 tests produces significant winner. Use 95% confidence calculator.
- Prioritise testing automated flows over campaigns (flow improvements compound indefinitely).
- STO: 5-15% improvement in open rates. Per-subscriber timing.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/08-testing-and-optimisation/

---

## 9. ANALYTICS & MEASUREMENT

### KPIs by Campaign Type

| Type | Primary KPI | Target |
|---|---|---|
| Welcome series | Conversion rate, RPR | 2.5x baseline |
| Abandoned cart | Recovery rate, RPR | $3+ RPR (top 10%) |
| Promotional | Revenue, CTR | 2-5% CTR |
| Nurture | Engagement | >20% open, >12% CTOR |
| Cold email | Positive reply rate | 3-5% |
| Newsletter | Open rate, CTR | >40% open, >5% CTR |

### Attribution
- U-shaped (40/40/20): best starting point. Incrementality testing: gold standard.
- Well-optimised ecommerce: email should drive 25-40% of total revenue.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/09-analytics-and-measurement/

---

## 10. COMPLIANCE

| Regulation | Consent? | Key Rules | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| **CAN-SPAM (US)** | No | Accurate headers, physical address, honour opt-outs 10 days | $51,744/email |
| **GDPR (EU)** | Yes | Right to erasure 30d, consent records 3-7 years | 4% turnover or €20M |
| **CASL (Canada)** | Yes | Purchase: 2yr. Inquiry: 6mo. Express = indefinite | $10M CAD |
| **Spam Act (AU)** | Yes | Consent + sender ID + unsubscribe 5 biz days | $2.22M AUD/day |

- One-click unsubscribe (RFC 8058): Required for bulk senders (5K+/day) to Gmail/Yahoo.
- Cold email: B2B legal in US/UK without consent. Consent required in Canada/Australia.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/10-compliance-and-privacy/

---

## 11. INDUSTRY PLAYBOOKS

19 vertical-specific playbooks with benchmarks, automation flows, and tactics:

- **Ecommerce DTC:** Email = 25-40% of revenue. Core three flows: welcome, cart, post-purchase. Engagement-based sending.
- **SaaS B2B:** Behaviour-based onboarding. One CTA per email. >20% open, >12% CTOR targets.
- **SaaS B2C:** 5% retention increase = 25-95% profit increase. Re-engage at 7 days inactive.
- **Newsletter/Creator:** Inflection at 10K subs. Revenue stack: sponsorships → paid → affiliates → products. Referral programmes grow 30-40% faster.
- **Nonprofit:** 3:1 ratio (value:ask). Mission-driven storytelling. Start end-of-year in November.

Also covers: Agency, Healthcare, Financial, Real Estate, Travel, Education, Retail, Events, B2B Manufacturing, Restaurant, Fitness, Media, Marketplace.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/11-industry-playbooks/

---

## 12. CHOOSING YOUR PLATFORM

### Platform Comparison

| Platform | Best For | Starting Price | Key Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Klaviyo | Ecommerce (Shopify) | Free (250 contacts) | Deep ecommerce data, predictive analytics |
| Mailchimp | Small businesses | Free (500 contacts) | Ease of use, broad feature set |
| ActiveCampaign | Automation-heavy | $15/mo | 135+ triggers and actions |
| HubSpot | B2B, inbound | Free (2K emails/mo) | CRM integration, full suite |
| Kit (ConvertKit) | Creators | Free (10K subs) | Creator-focused, simplicity |
| Brevo | Multi-channel | Free (300 emails/day) | Email + SMS + chat, volume pricing |
| beehiiv | Newsletters | Free (2.5K subs) | Growth tools, ad network |
| Omnisend | Ecommerce multi-channel | Free (250 contacts) | Email + SMS + push in one workflow |
| SmartrMail | Shopify ecommerce | Free (1K subs) | ML product recs, easiest ecommerce email |
| Bento | Developers, SaaS | $30/mo | API-first, MCP integration, SOC 2 |
| Postmark | Transactional | Free (100 emails/mo) | 99%+ delivery, sub-1s |

### Budget Guide
- **Under 500 subs:** Any free tier. Just start.
- **500-5K:** Brevo ~$25/mo, MailerLite ~$10/mo, Kit free tier.
- **5K-25K:** Klaviyo $60-150/mo (ecommerce), ActiveCampaign $49/mo (automation).
- Choose for where you'll be in 12 months. Migration at 25K with 15 automations is a project.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/12-choosing-your-platform/

---

## 13. COLD EMAIL

### Infrastructure (critical)
- **NEVER send from primary domain.** Buy 3-5 separate domains. Warm 2-4 weeks.
- Limit: 10-30 emails per inbox per day. Use dedicated cold email tool (NOT marketing ESP).

### Writing Cold Emails
- **Optimal length: 50-125 words.** Personalised opening → problem/observation → value prop → soft CTA.
- Interest-based CTAs: 2-3x more replies than meeting requests.

### Personalisation Levels
| Level | Reply Rate | Scale |
|---|---|---|
| Hyper-personalised (5+ min) | 15-25% | 20-30/day |
| Semi-personalised (1-2 min) | 8-15% | 50-100/day |
| Segmented (template/segment) | 3-8% | 100s/day |

### Follow-Up
4 emails over 2-3 weeks. Each MUST add new value. Breakup email = 2-3x reply rate of mid-sequence.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/13-cold-email-and-b2b-outbound/

---

## 14. AI & EMAIL

### Where AI Excels
- Subject lines (80% comparable to human, 10% of time), send-time optimisation (10-25% lift), segmentation/churn prediction, first drafts.

### Where AI Falls Short
- Brand voice consistency, strategic decisions, emotional nuance, creative breakthroughs.

### Human-AI Workflow
1. Brief AI with context → 2. Generate draft → 3. Edit for brand voice → 4. A/B test → 5. Feed results back.

### MCP Integration
- Model Context Protocol enables AI to interact with email platforms through natural language.
- Bento offers MCP server integration for managing email from within developer tools.

> Full chapter: https://emailmarketingskill.com/14-ai-and-the-future-of-email/

---

## APPENDIX: BENCHMARKS

### By Industry

| Industry | Avg Open Rate | Avg CTR | Avg Unsub |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ecommerce | 15-20% | 2-3% | 0.2% |
| SaaS/Tech | 20-25% | 2-3% | 0.2% |
| Financial | 20-25% | 2.5-3.5% | 0.15% |
| Healthcare | 20-25% | 2-3% | 0.15% |
| Education | 25-30% | 3-4% | 0.1% |
| Nonprofit | 25-30% | 2.5-3.5% | 0.1% |
| Media | 20-25% | 4-5% | 0.1% |
| Retail | 15-20% | 2-3% | 0.2% |

### By Email Type

| Type | Open Rate | CTR |
|---|---|---|
| Welcome | 50-60% | 5-8% |
| Abandoned Cart | 40-50% | 5-10% |
| Transactional | 60-80% | 5-15% |
| Promotional | 15-20% | 2-3% |
| Newsletter | 20-30% | 3-5% |
| Win-Back | 10-15% | 1-2% |

### ROI by Channel

| Channel | Avg ROI |
|---|---|
| Email | $36-42 per $1 |
| SMS | $20-25 per $1 |
| SEO | $15-20 per $1 |
| Social (Paid) | $2-5 per $1 |

### Key Thresholds

| Metric | Healthy | Warning | Critical |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bounce Rate | < 2% | 2-5% | > 5% |
| Complaint Rate | < 0.05% | 0.05-0.1% | > 0.1% |
| Unsub Rate | < 0.3% | 0.3-0.5% | > 0.5% |
| List Growth | > 2%/mo | 0-2% | Negative |

### Email Frequency Guide

| Industry | Recommended |
|---|---|
| Ecommerce DTC | 3-5x/week |
| SaaS B2B | 1-2x/week |
| Newsletter | Daily to 3x/week |
| Nonprofit | 1-2x/month |
| Retail | 3-5x/week |

> Full benchmarks: https://emailmarketingskill.com/appendix-a-benchmarks/
> Frequency guide: https://emailmarketingskill.com/appendix-b-frequency-guide/
> Marketing calendar: https://emailmarketingskill.com/appendix-c-calendar/
> Methodology: https://emailmarketingskill.com/appendix-d-methodology/